Image description

Woodburne Mansion on the Heights of Darby

Designed in 1906 by Horace Trumbauer from stone, steel, and strong timber to be a summer home for the heirs to the Pennsylvania Railroad fortune of Thomas A. Scott, the Mansion was purchased by the Sisters of the Divine Redeemeer in 1936 for an orphanage and place of refuge, and then, in 2016 purchased by Delaware County for a park.

History    

Measured Drawings

Video - New Era for Woodburne 



Click here to edit

Click here

These are passages from a  2022 report in J&M Preservation's report on responsible suspended occupancy. 


https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:VA6C2:396a40c6-083d-4309-97eb-4316922f5a6c


P14 Within the Rear Wing, we were able to access the entire western portion of the building for all levels. There was no access to the northeast corner of the sub-basement and basement levels. All of the rooms east of the north-south central corridor were inaccessible at the basement, first, and second levels. 


pg 15 The masonry walls that line the north and south sides of the corridor appeared to be in good condition, with the exception of the attic level above the steel beams which appeared to be actively moving. There are several unbraced masonry piers along the north side of the corridor now that the floor framing no longer acts as a diaphragm to tie the walls together. The floor joists pockets along both the north and south walls of the Gallery Hall appeared to be in good condition and could be reused. We traversed into the Library from the Vestibule where the ceiling finish was partially collapsed. The floor was relatively in-tact and the overhead framing was exposed. The second floor wood joist framing above the Library appeared to be in fair condition, but the ceiling framing hanging from the floor joists appeared to be wet and an imminent collapse. The exposed steel beams of the second floor appeared to be in good condition and capable of supporting loads. 


pg 16  The steel beams spanning north-south are intact and appear to be stable which help maintain the integrity of the structure by keeping the bearing walls tied together. The brick wall to the west is exposed and also appears to be stable. The floor joists are out of their pockets at both the first and second levels, but the pockets appear to be stable (see Figure 8). 



pg 18 Generally, the exterior mass masonry walls are stable, as well as the interior load bearing walls. With the exception of the top of the masonry piers in the Gallery, we did not note any locations where the walls were not plumb or true. The steel beams are also stable and are working to keep the walls stitched together in instances where the wood floor framing has collapsed.  



Exterior Façade -Masonry The stone façade is in very good condition and the thick painted stucco coat is largely in-tact with the exception of areas around damaged downspouts and gutters. Pg 24


With regard to the overall future of the site, it is recommended that the County further evaluate the benefits of a public/private partnership since the reuse of the building will be costly, and input from community stakeholders is necessary for its successful preservation. In our conversations with the Friends of Woodburne Mansion, namely, their Chair – Harold Finigan, they are willing and able to raise funds for the stabilization and reuse of the building. Mr. Finigan has a proven track record for coordinating public/private partnerships, namely at Fort Mifflin on the Delaware. While the partnership can be difficult to get off the ground, this type of collaborative effort between an established non-profit and a publicly owned asset can prove very successful.  J&M Preservation can point directly to Eastern State Penitentiary Historic Site, Inc. (ESP) as an ideal example of how this relationship operates and who we have worked closely with for twenty years. ESP is a charitable nonprofit organization that runs and maintains the City of Philadelphia owned historic landmark property. The nonprofit organization is responsible for the fundraising to operate and maintain the facility, which often allows more avenues for funding capital improvements that a municipality may not be able to do. Mr. Finigan’s experience with Fort Mifflin within the City of Philadelphia echoes how a nonprofit can manage operations, preservation and programming of a National Historic Landmark, in a similar manner as Eastern State.   We recognize that the Friends group may have a different overall goal for the Woodburne site than Delaware County’s Planning Department and the adopted Master Site Development Plan prepared by BCM Engineers in 2018. It is important to note that planning for the open space will inform the future reuse of the mansion and vice versa. From its historic roots as a farmstead with greenhouses to a private residence (also with greenhouses)4, to the later orphanage turned nursing facility for a religious order, all of these pasts should be taken into consideration, respected, and inform the future of the site. Generally, we have found that most organizations that take on the responsibility of caretaker of an historic site are well versed in respecting its past while considering the importance of the surrounding community and their needs. The community surrounding the mansion are its most valued stakeholders, therefore, working with these groups is truly the only way to bring the site into the future and maintain its place in history. We recognize that community meetings were held in 2017 to inform the master planning process, but as the site moves into the post pandemic era, we recommend holding additional meetings as the community needs and views may have changed. ......


 pg 27

Rear Wing The Rear Wing was accessed from the covered porch on the north elevation, which enters at the basement level due to the grade change. A metal stair leads to the sub-basement level which is corroded but stable. The stairwell to the upper levels was utilized during the assessment but the railing has been demolished at the first level, 101 Stairs, and the stringer has pulled away from the wall at the second level, 201 Stair. From the sub-basement, the concrete floors and the inside face of the foundation walls were in good condition. The interior partition walls, constructed from a combination of brick and masonry block are also in good condition. The steel framing above the SB03 Boiler Put was wet and lightly corroded, as well as the framing above SB04, however it appears stable. The ceiling above SB05 is constructed of ribbed brick vaults with steel. Steel reinforcement bars span in the north-south direction and are lightly corroded. The adjacent brick is jacked from the expansive forces of the corrosion. The wood joist framing above SB02 is very wet with mold and efflorescence on the joists. The pipework has collapsed or in a state of collapse.  A brick vault ceiling is above SB06 which are also very wet. Access was not available to SB01, SB08, and SB09 due to the collapse above. These areas are very wet, with standing water on the concrete floor slab. Two lines of pipe shoring was installed in SB09 that support steel I-beams, below the collapsed  basemen floor joists (see Figure 10).